Saturday , December 15 2018
Home / V. Ramanan: Concerted Action / Angela Nagle — The Left Case Against Open Borders

Angela Nagle — The Left Case Against Open Borders

Summary:
Angela Nagle — The Left Case Against Open BordersAngela Nagle writing for American Affairs:The destruction and abandonment of labor politics means that, at present, immigration issues can only play out within the framework of a culture war, fought entirely on moral grounds. In the heightened emotions of America’s public debate on migration, a simple moral and political dichotomy prevails. It is “right-wing” to be “against immigration” and “left-wing” to be “for immigration.” But the economics of migration tell a different story.…Today’s well-intentioned activists have become the useful idiots of big business. With their adoption of “open borders” advocacy—and a fierce moral absolutism that regards any limit to migration as an unspeakable evil—any criticism of the exploitative system of

Topics:
V. Ramanan considers the following as important: ,

This could be interesting, too:

Dan Crawford writes Open thread Dec. 14, 2018

John Quiggin writes Brexit: The endgame

Lars Syll writes Your model is internally consistent? So what!

Dean Baker writes Trade: It’s still about class, not country

Angela Nagle — The Left Case Against Open Borders

Angela Nagle writing for American Affairs:

The destruction and abandonment of labor politics means that, at present, immigration issues can only play out within the framework of a culture war, fought entirely on moral grounds. In the heightened emotions of America’s public debate on migration, a simple moral and political dichotomy prevails. It is “right-wing” to be “against immigration” and “left-wing” to be “for immigration.” But the economics of migration tell a different story.

Today’s well-intentioned activists have become the useful idiots of big business. With their adoption of “open borders” advocacy—and a fierce moral absolutism that regards any limit to migration as an unspeakable evil—any criticism of the exploitative system of mass migration is effectively dismissed as blasphemy. Even solidly leftist politicians, like Bernie Sanders in the United States and Jeremy Corbyn in the United Kingdom, are accused of “nativism” by critics if they recognize the legitimacy of borders or migration restriction at any point. This open borders radicalism ultimately benefits the elites within the most powerful countries in the world, further disempowers organized labor, robs the developing world of desperately needed professionals, and turns workers against workers.

[the title is the link]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *