Thursday , January 18 2018
Home / Lars P. Syll / The thing that people just don’t get about statistics

The thing that people just don’t get about statistics

Summary:
The thing that people just don’t get about statistics The thing that people just don’t get is that is just how easy it is to get “p less than .01” using uncontrolled comparisons … Statistics educators, including myself, have to take much of the blame for this sad state of affairs. We go around sending the message that it’s possible to get solid causal inference from experimental or observational data, as long as you have a large enough sample size and a good identification strategy. People such as the authors of the above article then take us at our word, gather large datasets, find identification strategies, and declare victory. The thing we didn’t say in our textbooks was that this approach doesn’t work so well in the absence of clean data and strong

Topics:
Lars Pålsson Syll considers the following as important:

This could be interesting, too:

Lars Pålsson Syll writes What should we do with econometrics?

Lars Pålsson Syll writes Deaton-Cartwright-Senn-Gelman on the limited value of randomization

Lars Pålsson Syll writes Big Data Bullshit

Lars Pålsson Syll writes Texas sharpshooter fallacy

The thing that people just don’t get about statistics

The thing that people just don’t get is that is just how easy it is to get “p less than .01” using uncontrolled comparisons …

Statistics educators, including myself, have to take much of the blame for this sad state of affairs.

The thing that people just don’t get about statisticsWe go around sending the message that it’s possible to get solid causal inference from experimental or observational data, as long as you have a large enough sample size and a good identification strategy.

People such as the authors of the above article then take us at our word, gather large datasets, find identification strategies, and declare victory. The thing we didn’t say in our textbooks was that this approach doesn’t work so well in the absence of clean data and strong theory …

The issue is not that “p less than .01” is useless—there are times when “p less than .01” represents strong evidence—but rather that this p-value says very little on its own.

Andrew Gelman

Advertisements
Lars Pålsson Syll
Lars Jörgen Pålsson Syll (born November 5, 1957) is a Swedish economist who is a Professor of Social Studies and Associate professor of Economic History at Malmö University College. Pålsson Syll has been a prominent contributor to the economic debate in Sweden over the global financial crisis that began in 2008.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *