Sunday , September 20 2020
Home / Lars P. Syll / Collider attributes in graph theory (wonkish)

Collider attributes in graph theory (wonkish)

Summary:
Collider attributes in graph theory (wonkish) Why would two independent variables suddenly become dependent when we condition on their common effect? To answer this question, we return again to the definition of conditioning as filtering by the value of the conditioning variable. When we condition on Z, we limit our comparisons to cases in which Z takes the same value. But remember that Z depends, for its value, on X and Y. So, when comparing cases where Z takes some value, any change in value of X must be compensated for by a change in the value of Y — otherwise, the value of Z would change as well. The reasoning behind this attribute of colliders — that conditioning on a collision node produces a dependence between the node’s parents — can be difficult

Topics:
Lars Pålsson Syll considers the following as important:

This could be interesting, too:

Lars Pålsson Syll writes Dirichlet’s principle — sophisticated simplicity

Lars Pålsson Syll writes Keynes on the additivity fallacy

Lars Pålsson Syll writes Econometrics — science based on questionable presumptions

Lars Pålsson Syll writes The dangers of calling your pet cat a dog

Collider attributes in graph theory (wonkish)

Why would two independent variables suddenly become dependent when we condition on their common effect? To answer this question, we return again to the definition of conditioning as filtering by the value of the conditioning variable. When we condition on Z, we limit our comparisons to cases in which Z takes the same value. But remember that Z depends, for its value, on X and Y. So, when comparing cases where Z takes some value, any change in value of X must be compensated for by a change in the value of Y — otherwise, the value of Z would change as well.

The reasoning behind this attribute of colliders — that conditioning on a collision node produces a dependence between the node’s parents — can be difficult to grasp at first. In the most basic situation where Z = X + Y, and X and Y are independent variables, we have the follow- ing logic: If I tell you that X = 3, you learn nothing about the potential value of Y, because the two numbers are independent. On the other hand, if I start by telling you that Z = 10, then telling you that X = 3 immediately tells you that Y must be 7. Thus, X and Y are dependent, given that Z = 10.

People usually find this collider attribute rather perplexing. Why? My guess is the reason is most people wrongly think there can be no correlation without causation.

Professor at Malmö University. Primary research interest - the philosophy, history and methodology of economics.