Sunday , May 19 2024
Home / Mike Norman Economics / Ann Pettifore – On Theresa May, Danny DeVito and ‘other people’s money’.

Ann Pettifore – On Theresa May, Danny DeVito and ‘other people’s money’.

Summary:
This a brilliant explanation of how the British fiscal system works, and probably the American system is similar, I would have thought. Ann Petrified demolishes the myth about left wing governments 'spending other people's money'.Governments either borrow money from their own central banks, she says, or issue bonds to borrow the money from the private sector. This money is then invested into the UK building its infrastructure and public services, etc, creating jobs which helps the private sector to flourish and grow. And with the increased GDP the government gets the money back in taxes to help pay off the loans.Some people on the right might still see this as the government taxing too much, and yet their job, or the security of their job, or their next decent pay rise, may well depend

Topics:
Mike Norman considers the following as important:

This could be interesting, too:

Lars Pålsson Syll writes DSGE models — a total waste of time

Lars Pålsson Syll writes Max von Sydow — non plus ultra

Peter Radford writes Lost opportunities?

Joel Eissenberg writes Oh, Elon!

Ann Pettifore - On Theresa May, Danny DeVito and ‘other people’s money’.

This a brilliant explanation of how the British fiscal system works, and probably the American system is similar, I would have thought. Ann Petrified demolishes the myth about left wing governments 'spending other people's money'.

Governments either borrow money from their own central banks, she says, or issue bonds to borrow the money from the private sector. This money is then invested into the UK building its infrastructure and public services, etc, creating jobs which helps the private sector to flourish and grow. And with the increased GDP the government gets the money back in taxes to help pay off the loans.

Some people on the right might still see this as the government taxing too much, and yet their job, or the security of their job, or their next decent pay rise, may well depend on this government expenditure, but they don't know this as they can't see the link. Ann Pettifore's explanation of how the government's fiscal system works should be made into a video, or a short film, or even picture book so that people can understand it easier.

But this is the really good bit, pension and insurance companies really want the government bonds because of their security. The government pays interest on these bonds and the right might get concerned about government borrowing and spending, but when the pensions, or the insurance policies, pay out, people get the money back that they had paid in taxes - the profits the pension fund made came from the taxes that were paid in. In other words, the government borrowed to invest into the economy making everyone richer, and from this new wealth the government was able to collect the necessary taxes to pay off the loans, which also boosts the pensions.

So the government isn't taking your hard earned money away art all, because it actually made you a lot richer and in the end you would have made a net gain, even after taxes, while your health services, your schools, your roads, and all public services improved the quality of your lives. Win, win!

But there's more, what if the government sometimes saved people's money by issuing the bonds, because the interest paid was below the rate of inflation.

PEF Council member Ann Pettifor explains how all governments finance their spending (and its not from taxation). She deconstructs Theresa May’s address to the Conservative Party Conference with its deliberate framing of Labour governments as tax raiders.
The use of the phrase “other people’s money” was not accidental. It was first used in the title of a famous work (1973) by Donald R. Cressy about the social psychology of embezzlement. The book was later made into a movieabout a corrupt corporate raider, and starred Danny de Vito and Gregory Peck. Mrs May’s speech writer wanted to imply that Labour governments are tax raiders.
That is both a calumny, but also a lie – twice over. First because no Labour government has ever run out of money – not even Clement Attlee’s which started life with public debt at 250% of national income, and then spent enormous sums creating the NHS, affordable housing, a public education system etc. As a result of that spending, public debt as a share of GDP fell precipitously, because the Labour government increased the nation’s income, through well-paid employment. Good, well-paid employment in turn generated tax revenues – to pay for the borrowing, and pay down the public debt.
Second, no government – including today’s Conservative government – finances spending from taxation. Instead governments finance spending by borrowing from their own Bank, the Bank of England, or from capital markets. If that borrowing creates employment and increases income, then tax revenues accrue to HMRC, and is used to pay for the borrowing. To keep the public finances balanced at a time of private economic failure, it is vital for government to borrow and spend, to expand the nation’s income and thereby to generate the tax revenues needed to repay the borrowing, and keep the public finances in order.
The Progressive Economy Forum
See also, The Myth of Debt
The Herald
Mike Norman
Mike Norman is an economist and veteran trader whose career has spanned over 30 years on Wall Street. He is a former member and trader on the CME, NYMEX, COMEX and NYFE and he managed money for one of the largest hedge funds and ran a prop trading desk for Credit Suisse.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *