Tuesday , November 5 2024
Home / Mike Norman Economics / Simon Wren-Lewis — The biggest economic policy mistake of the last decade, and it had nothing to do with academic economists

Simon Wren-Lewis — The biggest economic policy mistake of the last decade, and it had nothing to do with academic economists

Summary:
The narrative rules. Whoever controls the narrative controls high ground regarding the opinion of politicians and the public. The second point is that this academic debate had zero impact on politicians. In that sense Cooper’s article is of purely academic concern. Austerity was not begun because politicians chose the wrong academic macroeconomists to take advice from, and the fact that the Keynesians won the debate therefore had no impact on what they did. The academic debate was in this sense a complete sideshow. I think many Keynesian academics understood that: it was a fight we had to win but we were under no illusions it would change anything. I wrote in 2012 that if all academics were united we might have an impact on public opinion, but that illusion did not last very long and

Topics:
Mike Norman considers the following as important:

This could be interesting, too:

Mike Norman writes Politicians Who Want Us to Live Beyond Our Means — Peter Cooper

Mike Norman writes Lars P. Syll — a primary reason for the rise of inequality

Mike Norman writes Revealed: Americans care more about social needs than deficits — John Duda

Mike Norman writes Robert Heilbroner — The Embarrassment of Economics: Weekend Reading


The narrative rules. Whoever controls the narrative controls high ground regarding the opinion of politicians and the public.
The second point is that this academic debate had zero impact on politicians. In that sense Cooper’s article is of purely academic concern. Austerity was not begun because politicians chose the wrong academic macroeconomists to take advice from, and the fact that the Keynesians won the debate therefore had no impact on what they did. The academic debate was in this sense a complete sideshow. I think many Keynesian academics understood that: it was a fight we had to win but we were under no illusions it would change anything. I wrote in 2012 that if all academics were united we might have an impact on public opinion, but that illusion did not last very long and Brexit showed it was indeed an illusion.

I think this lack of influence that academic economics can have is not understood by many. It often suits some heterodox economists to pretend otherwise. Economists can be influential, but only when politicians want to listen, or the media is prepared to confront them with academic knowledge. For example politicians have not done nearly enough to ensure another financial crisis does not happen, but that isn’t because economists have told them not to or have not shown them how to do so. It is because politics prevents it happening....
Mainly Macro
The biggest economic policy mistake of the last decade, and it had nothing to do with academic economists
Simon Wren-Lewis | Emeritus Professor of Economics, Oxford University
Mike Norman
Mike Norman is an economist and veteran trader whose career has spanned over 30 years on Wall Street. He is a former member and trader on the CME, NYMEX, COMEX and NYFE and he managed money for one of the largest hedge funds and ran a prop trading desk for Credit Suisse.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *