Summary:
I have been running into comments about “top down” versus “bottom up” inflation analysis over the years, mainly on Twitter. The usual context is a conventional economist arguing that “bottom up inflation analysis is defective” for some reason or another. I have not seen a long form analysis justifying this, rather this was drive by snark. I have seen this more often as people are taking victory laps for inflation forecasting.Since I am not huge fan of the people making the comments, I cannot offer a strong version of their views. I will instead offer a guess at what they were driving at, and explain why I think inflation analysis should be “bottom up.” (I discuss this in Section 3.3 of Breakeven Inflation Analysis.)...Bond EconomicsOn Bottom Up Inflation AnalysisBrian
Topics:
Mike Norman considers the following as important:
This could be interesting, too:
I have been running into comments about “top down” versus “bottom up” inflation analysis over the years, mainly on Twitter. The usual context is a conventional economist arguing that “bottom up inflation analysis is defective” for some reason or another. I have not seen a long form analysis justifying this, rather this was drive by snark. I have seen this more often as people are taking victory laps for inflation forecasting.Since I am not huge fan of the people making the comments, I cannot offer a strong version of their views. I will instead offer a guess at what they were driving at, and explain why I think inflation analysis should be “bottom up.” (I discuss this in Section 3.3 of Breakeven Inflation Analysis.)...Bond EconomicsOn Bottom Up Inflation AnalysisBrian
Topics:
Mike Norman considers the following as important:
This could be interesting, too:
NewDealdemocrat writes The Household Survey isn’t the only data series sending up caution flares
Joel Eissenberg writes Is China eating our EV lunch?
Angry Bear writes Republican U.S. States Sue EPA over Strict Power Plant Emission Rules
Angry Bear writes Clawback of money looted by Cerberus, de la Torre, and MPT from Steward Health Care
I have been running into comments about “top down” versus “bottom up” inflation analysis over the years, mainly on Twitter. The usual context is a conventional economist arguing that “bottom up inflation analysis is defective” for some reason or another. I have not seen a long form analysis justifying this, rather this was drive by snark. I have seen this more often as people are taking victory laps for inflation forecasting.Bond EconomicsSince I am not huge fan of the people making the comments, I cannot offer a strong version of their views. I will instead offer a guess at what they were driving at, and explain why I think inflation analysis should be “bottom up.” (I discuss this in Section 3.3 of Breakeven Inflation Analysis.)...
On Bottom Up Inflation Analysis
Brian Romanchuk
http://www.bondeconomics.com/2022/07/on-bottom-up-inflation-analysis.html