by Paper here mentions how the required dogmatism in the Platonist dialogic methodology can prevent education…Multiplist and absolutist epistemologies are incompatiblewith dialogic teaching. In the words of Bakhtin (1984), “bothrelativism and dogmatism equally exclude all argumentation,all authentic dialogue, by making it either unnecessary ...orimpossible (p. 69). Despite their differences, both multiplistsand absolutists rely on fundamentally monologic assump-tions about knowledge: They either discount a possibility ofshared understanding or insist on an absolute truth (Sidorkin,1999). The thing is with the Platonist Art Degreed Monetarists, they are NOT attempting education… they are imposing policy… they already have been educated…So these authors caution the reader against the use of
Topics:
Mike Norman considers the following as important:
This could be interesting, too:
Jeremy Smith writes UK workers’ pay over 6 years – just about keeping up with inflation (but one sector does much better…)
Robert Vienneau writes The Emergence of Triple Switching and the Rarity of Reswitching Explained
Lars Pålsson Syll writes Schuldenbremse bye bye
Robert Skidelsky writes Lord Skidelsky to ask His Majesty’s Government what is their policy with regard to the Ukraine war following the new policy of the government of the United States of America.
Paper here mentions how the required dogmatism in the Platonist dialogic methodology can prevent education…
Multiplist and absolutist epistemologies are incompatiblewith dialogic teaching. In the words of Bakhtin (1984), “bothrelativism and dogmatism equally exclude all argumentation,all authentic dialogue, by making it either unnecessary ...orimpossible (p. 69). Despite their differences, both multiplistsand absolutists rely on fundamentally monologic assump-tions about knowledge: They either discount a possibility ofshared understanding or insist on an absolute truth (Sidorkin,1999).
The thing is with the Platonist Art Degreed Monetarists, they are NOT attempting education… they are imposing policy… they already have been educated…
So these authors caution the reader against the use of dogmatism in education… ok maybe you could see that… but in policy advocacy nobody is trying to educate anyone…
Imposing policy is NOT EDUCATION… (btw MMT academics would do well to continuously remind themselves of this) … so Platonist Art Degree dogmatism becomes again preferred…
So it’s really out of place for MMT academic people to whine and complain that “you haven’t read the MMT literature!” like they do all the time… I would remind them that these people are NOT in your f-ing classrooms… They are advocating for policies…