Tag Archives: Statistics & Econometrics

Econometrics — science based on unwarranted assumptions There is first of all the central question of methodology — the logic of applying the method of multiple correlation to unanalysed economic material, which we know to be non-homogeneous through time. If we are dealing with the action of numerically measurable, independent forces, adequately analysed so that we were dealing with independent atomic factors and between them completely comprehensive,...

Causal inference in social sciences (student stuff) .[embedded content]

The main ideas behind bootstrapping (student stuff) .[embedded content]

Propensity score matching vs. regression (student stuff) .[embedded content]

.[embedded content]

Bradford Hill — comment trouver de la causalité dans des corrélations .[embedded content]

How to achieve ‘external validity’ There is a lot of discussion in the literature on beginning with experiments and then going on to check “external validity”. But to imagine that there is a scientific way to achieve external validity is, for the most part, a delusion … RCTs do not in themselves tell us anything about the traits of populations in other places and at other times. Hence, no matter how large the population from which we draw our random samples...

Randomizations creating illusions of knowledge The advantage of randomised experiments in describing populations creates an illusion of knowledge … This happens because of the propensity of scientific journals to value so-called causal findings and not to value findings where no (so-called) causality is found. In brief, it is arguable that we know less than we think we do. To see this, suppose—as is indeed the case in reality—that thousands of researchers...

Why the idea of causation cannot be a purely statistical one If contributions made by statisticians to the understanding of causation are to be taken over with advantage in any specific field of inquiry, then what is crucial is that the right relationship should exist between statistical and subject-matter concerns … Where the ultimate aim of research is not prediction per se but rather causal explanation, an idea of causation that is expressed in terms of...

Structural equation modelling (student stuff) .[embedded content] This is a good introduction to some of the basic thoughts behind the use of SEMs. But — for the controversial question if SEMs really can be considered causal, yours truly highly recommends reading Kenneth Bollen’s and Judea Pearl’s Eight myths about causality and structural equation models.