from Lars Syll Data without theory can lead to bogus inferences … Before being comforted or alarmed, consider whether it makes sense to extrapolate. Is there a persuasive reason why the future can be predicted simply by looking at the past? Or is that wishful thinking? Or nothing at all? … Remember that even random flips can yield striking, even stunning, patterns that mean nothing at all … A statistical comparison of two things is similarly unpersuasive unless there is a logical reason...
Read More »American wealth redistribution 1989-2016
Open thread May 21, 2019
Trump’s trade war with China is waged to make the rich richer
from Dean Baker Donald Trump seems determined to double down and keep pressing forward on his trade war with China. He promises more and higher tariffs, apparently not realizing that U.S. consumers are the ones paying these taxes — not China’s government or corporations. While tariffs clearly impose a cost on people in the United States, this cost could be justified as a weapon to change a trading partner’s harmful practices. During his campaign, Trump pledged to wage a trade war with...
Read More »Chicago economics — garbage in, gospel out
from Lars Syll Every dollar of increased government spending must correspond to one less dollar of private spending. Jobs created by stimulus spending are offset by jobs lost from the decline in private spending. We can build roads instead of factories, but fiscal stimulus can’t help us to build more of both. This form of “crowding out” is just accounting, and doesn’t rest on any perceptions or behavioral assumptions. John Cochrane The problem with this view is, of course, that it is...
Read More »U-shape vs. L-shape income redistribution trends – 10 countries
Women as workers
from Jayati Ghosh One of the enduring myths about capitalism that continues to be perpetuated in mainstream economic textbooks and other economic pedagogy is that labour supply is somehow exogenous to the economic system. The supply of labour is typically assumed (especially in standard growth theories) to be determined by the rate of population growth, which in turn is also seen as “outside” the economic system rather than in interaction with it. The reality is of course very different:...
Read More »Don’t think like a freak
from Lars Syll In their latest book, Think Like a Freak, co-authors Steven Levitt and Stephen Dubner tell a story about meeting David Cameron in London before he was Prime Minister. They told him that the U.K.’s National Health Service — free, unlimited, lifetime health care — was laudable but didn’t make practical sense. “We tried to make our point with a thought experiment,” they write … Rather than seeing the humor and realizing that health care is just like any other part of the...
Read More »Open thread May 17, 2019
Employment for all
from Asad Zaman Global experience shows that market economies create massive inequalities, enriching the top one per cent, while leaving the bottom of the population far behind. One key to prosperity is to provide productive jobs for all who would like to participate in the production process. Unfortunately, contemporary macroeconomics, which was blind to the possibility of the global financial crisis, is not equipped with the ideas and tools required to create full employment....
Read More »